answers: 21

  1. Rodion
    07.10.2024

    What about compatibility with older cameras like Sony NEX5?

    Reply

    • Arkady Shapoval
      07.10.2024

      no way, most likely either the camera will not turn on, or AF will not work at all. Only cameras with phase sensors.

      Reply

      • Rodion
        08.10.2024

        And they specifically don’t provide a drawing of the optical scheme so that I don’t have to comment on it?)

        Reply

      • Andy From Far Away
        08.10.2024

        Maybe it's similar to this one and they don't want the original's lawyers to "comment" on it? )

        Reply

      • Rodion
        08.10.2024

        Ouch, take a bowl of rice and go to the sanatorium!

        Reply

      • Arkady Shapoval
        09.10.2024

        Most likely, they simply forgot to add it to their site. Recently, they have been easily calculating and releasing their own schemes. They have their own glasses (types of glass) for which they calculate. It will not work to just take and make according to the LEICA APO-SUMMICRON-SL 1:2/35 ASPH. scheme, because Leica has its own park of specific glasses, tolerances, etc., and this is just a conceptual scheme. And in general, you can always find “similarity”, because the basic principles have not gone anywhere.

        Reply

      • Rodion
        09.10.2024

        Well, there are no specific glasses. The Schott, Hoya and CDGM catalogues do not differ much in glass parameters. Anyway, in the world of +- everything has (or had) a tendency towards unification. Yes, it happens that for some Schottovsky TFK there is no complete Chinese analogue - but there are engineers who can recalculate the scheme. In general, the coverage of the Abbe plane-refraction is the same for the designated catalogues. That is, any Leica lens can be reproduced on Chinese glass.

        Reply

      • Rodion
        09.10.2024

        Specifically, Meike, in my opinion, never shows drawings of their circuits.

        Reply

  2. Alex
    07.10.2024

    Arkady, thanks for the review. It's not very clear why the direct competitors of this lens from Viltrox and Youngnuo (for E and Z), as well as from Samyang (for E) were not mentioned. For L-mount, yes, at the moment it seems that this is the only budget autofocus lens.
    Perhaps one could also say something about the expected 7Artisans 35/1.8 (E/Z/L).
    The lens announcement mentioned the SE line:
    “Meike … will introduce … the upcoming high-margin SE product line”
    I think this wording can be interpreted as “cheap and SErdito”.
    In conclusion, there is a typo in point 6 – its range starts at F/2.

    Reply

    • Arkady Shapoval
      09.10.2024

      Fixed

      Reply

  3. Sergei
    10.10.2024

    The Chinese claim that Meike is preparing a new PRO line. The announcement of the first swallow is October 17, it will be 55/1,8, then there will be 15/1,8, 24/1,8, 85/1,8

    Reply

  4. Sergun
    11.10.2024

    Can you show more bokeh shots?

    Reply

    • Arkady Shapoval
      11.10.2024

      can

      Reply

      • Sergun
        14.10.2024

        Added? Can't see anything Portrait / bokeh

        Reply

  5. wj
    14.10.2024

    Thanks for the review!
    There is a small typo in the specifications table: the lens hood is marked as LH58-P64, not LH58-P84.

    Reply

    • Arkady Shapoval
      14.10.2024

      Fixed

      Reply

  6. Dmitriy
    14.10.2024

    Arkady, where are the 10 shortcomings? Do you cite them quite often?

    Reply

    • Rodion
      14.10.2024

      In the jade lenses from the Great Sky Sun China there are no shortcomings, only advantages - so said the Chief. And if the skinny mongoose does not agree - then let him go to the sanatorium for water and a bowl of rice.

      Reply

    • Arkady Shapoval
      21.10.2024

      in my opinion, the main drawback is limited compatibility, the lens will only work with cameras that have phase focus sensors and only with the alpha line (it will not work on NEX, the camera will either not turn on, or neither autofocus nor aperture control will work). Otherwise, it is a really decent lens

      Reply

      • Dmitriy
        22.10.2024

        This lens is declared for Leica L bayonet, and S1R, S1, S5(1), S1H do not have phase sensors. Probably, it is not only about phase sensors.

        Reply

      • Arkady Shapoval
        22.10.2024

        my comment was about the model under Sony E/FE

        Reply

Reply

 

 

Top
mobility. computer